Version 16 (modified by lhella, 10 years ago)

--

MMT Template Review

The PCA MMT SIG has started a process for review of templates. A set of templates will be proposed for review by a submitter. The proposals will be made publicly available and everyone is welcome to provide their comments.

  1. The first proposal is available here: http://15926.org/viewtopic.php?f=29&t=183&sid=4b5eb3ae631ab502f1e241e187db2c14, and has been submitted by Hans Teijgeler. The proposal is also available in the following zip file - Batch 1 for review. Any comments for the first batch of templates must be submitted before 13th December. Comments can be posted in the forum or by using the checklist (sending it to lillian.hella@…).
Review referenceProposalCommentsResolution
#1Batch 1 containing the following templates:
ClassificationOfIndividual,
ClassifiedDescriptionOfIndividual,
ClassifiedDescriptionOfIndividualInLanguage,
DescriptionOfIndividualWithClassifiedSign
Comments and responses the the comments are available in the forum:
http://15926.org/viewtopic.php?f=29&t=183&sid=4b5eb3ae631ab502f1e241e187db2c14
The comments and responses are also available as a file here.
Approved, with one change for template DescriptionOfIndividualWithClassifiedSign
#2Batch 2 containing the following templates:
ClassifiedDefinitionOfClassOfIndividual,
ClassifiedDescriptionOfClassOfIndividual,
ClassifiedDescriptionOfClassOfIndividualInLanguage,
ClassifiedDescriptionOfTemporalPart,
ClassifiedDescriptionOfTemporalPartInLanguage,
ClassifiedDescriptionOfWholeLifeIndividual,
ClassifiedDescriptionOfWholeLifeIndividualInLanguage,
ClassifiedIdentificationOfClassOfIndividual, ClassifiedIdentificationOfClassOfIndividualInLanguage,
ClassifiedIdentificationOfIndividual, 
ClassifiedIdentificationOfTemporalPart, 
ClassifiedIdentificationOfWholeLifeIndividual, 
DefinitionOfClassOfIndividualWithClassifiedSign, 
DescriptionOfClassOfIndividualWithClassifiedSign, 
DescriptionOfTemporalPartWithClassifiedSign, 
DescriptionOfWholeLifeIndividualWithClassifiedSign, 
IdentificationOfClassOfIndividualWithClassifiedSign, 
IdentificationOfTemporalPartWithClassifiedSign, 
IdentificationOfWholeLifeIndividualWithClassifiedSign
http://15926.org/viewtopic.php?f=29&t=196&p=874#p874

A checklist that is provided in the proposal package will give a good indication of what the reviewer should focus on for the review. After a review period collecting comments, there will be a voting process that involves the MMT Core. If you have questions about the review process, contact Lillian. For questions about the proposal, contact the submitter of the proposal.

Home
About PCA
Reference Data Services
Projects
Workgroups